Iconic Key Lime Pie Spots in the Florida Keys
No trip through the Florida Keys is truly complete without indulging in its most iconic dessert: Key lime pie. Tangy, creamy, and perfectly balanced with a buttery graham cracker crust, Key lime pie is more than a treat—it’s a cultural staple. Though you can find this dessert in nearly every corner of the Keys, a few places stand out as the absolute must-visit spots for the most authentic, delicious, and memorable slices. In this guide, we explore the most iconic Key lime pie spots from Key Largo to Key West, ensuring your sweet tooth is satisfied all the way down the Overseas Highway.
1. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory (Key Largo)
Located near the top of the Keys in Key Largo, Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory is a beloved destination. Often ranked among the best, their pie is everything you’d hope for—tart, smooth, and crowned with generous meringue or whipped cream. What sets this spot apart is the ambiance. The pie garden behind the café offers a relaxing and quirky environment with colorful tables, hammocks, and tropical plants, inviting you to sit down and truly savor the flavor.
Must-Try: Original Key lime pie with whipped cream topping
Location: 92220 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier, FL
2. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Key Largo)
This roadside gem is known for its comforting Florida Keys cuisine, and their Key lime pie is no exception. Mrs. Mac’s has been serving travelers and locals since the 1970s, and their pie—creamy, tangy, and made with real Key lime juice—has earned accolades from food critics and travel magazines alike. It's available with or without meringue, and both versions are worth trying.
Must-Try: Classic Key lime pie with graham cracker crust
Location: 99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
3. Morada Bay Beach Café (Islamorada)
If you want your Key lime pie with a view, Morada Bay Beach Café delivers. Located right on the beach, the open-air café is perfect for sunset dining. Their Key lime pie is a refined take on the classic dessert, served elegantly but without sacrificing the bold lime flavor that defines it. The setting—a white sand beach with swaying palms—enhances the experience.
Must-Try: Gourmet Key lime pie with tropical fruit garnish
Location: 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL
4. Chef Michael’s (Islamorada)
Chef Michael’s is known for upscale dining in the Keys, and while the seafood is the main attraction, the Key lime pie is a hidden treasure. Made in-house and served in individual portions, their pie emphasizes the perfect balance of tart and sweet. Many travelers rave about its rich texture and well-executed crust.
Must-Try: House-made Key lime pie with local flair
Location: 81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL
5. The Fish House (Key Largo)
Back in Key Largo, The Fish House offers a legendary version of the pie. Known for its commitment to fresh, local ingredients, The Fish House has become a reliable spot for not just seafood, but also desserts. Their Key lime pie features a beautifully smooth filling and a crust that has the perfect crunch. Bonus: they also sell frozen pies to go.
Must-Try: Key lime pie with whipped cream and lime zest
Location: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL
6. Lazy Days Restaurant (Islamorada)
This laid-back oceanfront eatery is a favorite among fishing charters and tourists alike. After a hearty seafood dinner, you’ll find that their Key lime pie hits the perfect note. It’s tart, not overly sweet, and comes in generous portions. Enjoy it while watching the boats come in or from a table right on the sand.
Must-Try: Frozen Key lime pie on a stick dipped in chocolate
Location: 79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL
7. Island Fish Company (Marathon Key)
Located midway down the Keys, this waterfront restaurant in Marathon is an ideal pit stop on your journey south. Their Key lime pie is a highlight of the menu, served chilled and often garnished with whipped cream and a slice of lime. The casual, open-air vibe makes it a fun place to relax and recharge.
Must-Try: Chilled Key lime pie with whipped cream
Location: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL
8. Blue Heaven (Key West)
When you arrive in Key West, Blue Heaven is a must-visit—both for its eclectic atmosphere and its towering slice of Key lime pie topped with a sky-high meringue. Located in Old Town and famous for roosters roaming the grounds, live music, and funky charm, this restaurant offers an unforgettable setting. Their pie is sweet, tangy, and visually stunning.
Must-Try: Mile-high meringue Key lime pie
Location: 729 Thomas St, Key West, FL
9. Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe (Key West)
Arguably the most famous name in the Key lime world, Kermit’s has become a pie empire. With a green-suited Kermit standing out front, this shop is a photo-op and dessert destination. The pie here is spot-on classic: creamy, tart, with just the right amount of sweetness. Kermit’s also offers chocolate-dipped Key lime pie on a stick, a frozen delight perfect for walking around Key West’s historic streets.
Must-Try: Chocolate-dipped Key lime pie on a stick
Location: 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL
10. Old Town Bakery (Key West)
If you're seeking a more artisanal version of the pie, stop by Old Town Bakery. Known for their pastries and bread, this bakery offers a Key lime pie with a rich, custard-like filling and a buttery crust that elevates the experience. Less touristy and more low-key, it's a local favorite.
Must-Try: Artisan Key lime pie with buttery crust
Location: 930 Eaton St, Key West, FL
Final Slice: Tasting the Keys One Pie at a Time
Whether you're a first-time visitor or a Florida Keys regular, enjoying Key lime pie is part of the journey. Each stop along the Overseas Highway has its own take on this classic dessert—from traditional recipes passed down generations to creative modern twists served with chocolate, fruit, or towering meringue. No matter how you slice it, the Key lime pie trail is one of the most rewarding culinary adventures in the Sunshine State.
If you’re road-tripping from Miami to Key West, take your time. Make these pie shops part of your itinerary, and you’ll not only enjoy incredible desserts—you’ll also discover the local flavors, characters, and communities that make the Keys unforgettable.
0 Comments